By Claire Hatcher-Smith
Powerful, fun, and mysterious, A Skeleton in the Closet is the perfect pick for middle-grade readers craving an exciting whodunit with heart.
Rating:
Summary:
Twelve-year-old Mizzy wants to prove to the world that she can solve mysteries just like Sherlock Holmes, despite a reputation for tall tales. A charming mystery series for middle-grade readers, starring a girl with Down syndrome — now in paperback!
Twelve-year-old Mizzy dreams of being a detective and she won’t let anything stand in her way — not her reputation for tall tales, or her embarrassing fear of escalators, and definitely not her Down syndrome. Dumped for the summer with cousins who’ve outgrown her, Mizzy feels even more sidelined than usual. But when she discovers Great Aunt Jane’s diaries in a locked wardrobe in their spare room, and realizes her aunt didn’t just die in her sleep but under suspicious circumstances, everything changes. What’s more . . . someone in the family appears to have been involved.
Under the guise of a family tree project for school, and armed with a brand-new set of Pip-Squeaks markers, Mizzy grabs the chance to prove herself to her cousins — and the world.
Summary from Amazon
Review:
A Skeleton in the Closet by Claire Hatcher-Smith offers a wonderful representation of life with Down syndrome, delivering an important reminder never to judge someone by a stereotype. With an engaging mystery, mindful storytelling, and empowering representation, this book deserves a spot on every classroom and library shelf.
First, Hatcher-Smith dismantles preconceived notions through her charming, determined protagonist, Mizzy. Mizzy defies assumptions at every turn, proving that a person is always so much more than a diagnosis. She is an independent, spirited young detective battling the doubts of those around her while staying true to what she loves. Mizzy is exactly the kind of character who helps young readers build genuine empathy and understanding, while giving kids with Down syndrome the chance to see themselves reflected as the hero of their own story.
In addition, the plot is lively and perfectly paced for a middle-grade audience. It moves quickly enough for kids to devour in just a couple of days, offering suspense, clues, and fun twists that keep readers guessing. Whether you have a reluctant reader at home or an avid mystery fan, this is an easy, captivating story to get lost in.
Finally, the intentionality behind the writing makes the story even more impactful. Accurately portraying Down syndrome while keeping the narrative fun and accessible for young readers requires care and understanding, and Hatcher-Smith delivers. She takes the time to reflect real-world experiences authentically, making Mizzy’s journey feel genuine rather than performative.
Ultimately, this is the exact type of book we need to get into the hands of young readers—one that entertains while quietly helping to build a more inclusive, empathetic world. Be sure to check out the first installment of The Mizzy Mysteries, A Skeleton in the Closet!
Thank you so much to Penguin Random House and Tundra Book Group for providing a complimentary copy in exchange for an honest review! All opinions are my own.
Leave a Reply